top of page

How Do You Know If SEO Is Successful? 11 Keys Signs

Wondering how you would know if your SEO strategy is successful?

We understand, especially with National SEO, where the competition is intense, that it's crucial to recognize the real signs of a winning strategy. And yes, figuring out what matters most can be overwhelming. But that’s why we’re here.

LeaseMyMarketing is here to make things simpler. In this article, we'll guide you through the key metrics that matter in SEO, showing you 11 unmistakable signs that your SEO efforts are not just working but excelling.

So get ready to dive deep into the nuts and bolts of successful SEO strategies and learn how to apply these insights to enhance your business online. Let's roll!

Key Takeaways

  • Signs of effective SEO include increased organic traffic, higher keyword rankings, improved CTR, and a decrease in bounce rate, all indicating your content resonates with audiences and search engines.

  • Conducting SEO audits is crucial to identify improvement areas and ensure your SEO strategies align with current best practices and search engine algorithms.

  • Achieving SEO success requires a sustained effort, with gradual changes and improvements over time.

1. Increased Organic Search Traffic

An image of SEO on top of a graph showing increasing traffic

Let's zero in on organic traffic—the real deal when it comes to measuring SEO success.

Picture this: You dive into Google Analytics or Bing Webmaster Tools and see your organic traffic numbers climbing.

Let me tell you now that that's not just random luck. This is a clear sign that your site is doing great on search engine results pages (SERPs) and your SEO efforts are paying off.

What's happening behind the scenes?

It's all about your content resonating with relevant searches, your site's progress in Google search results, and the strategic use of the right keywords. These combined efforts lead to an increase in search traffic and, importantly, traffic quality.

Essentially, your website becomes a magnet for users actively looking for what you offer. So, when you see those organic search traffic stats going up, give yourself a pat on the back—your SEO strategy is on the right track.

2. Higher Keyword Rankings

Now, let's shift our focus to keyword ranking. This is where the magic happens in search engine optimization.

Imagine this: You've been diligently working on your SEO strategy, adding relevant keywords, and fine-tuning your website content. Then, you check Google Search Console or use a free tool for keyword tracking, and voila—your site climbs up the search engine results page.

Getting to the first page is just part of it. It’s all about how your site ranks for competitive keywords. This jump in keyword ranking is a solid indicator that your SEO campaign is on the right path.

And you know what the best part is? It's all thanks to your clever SEO efforts—from your comprehensive keyword research to strategic page optimization.

Remember, every step you take towards improving your keyword rankings is a step toward greater SEO success.

3. Improved Click-Through Rate (CTR)

A mobile device showing the words 'click-through rate' on its screen

Click-through rate (CTR) is a vital metric and a key player in the SEO game.

Think of it as a measure of how effectively your meta descriptions and title tags are catching the eye of users in search engine results. It's a straightforward yet powerful indicator of how compelling your site appears at that critical first glance.

When you see your click-through rate number going up, it's a clear signal that your titles and descriptions are hitting the mark, grabbing attention, and drawing visitors in.

Now, being seen is just the first step. What matters is that they’re being clicked on. And with an increasing click-through rate, you're nailing that crucial aspect of SEO success.

4. Decreased Bounce Rate

Besides CTR, another SEO metric to watch out for is bounce rate. You can track this using SEO tools like Google Analytics. So, what is this metric all about?

Think of bounce rate as a digital thermometer for your website's health—it shows how many visitors come to your site but leave without engaging.

A high bounce rate might set off alarm bells, indicating that something's not quite clicking with your audience. But when you see that rate dropping, it's a clear sign that your website's content is hitting the sweet spot.

Simply put, you're attracting visitors, and most importantly, keeping them engaged with content that's relevant and interesting to their queries. A lower bounce rate is similar to a thumbs-up from your site visitors and just shows that your SEO efforts are steering in the right direction.

5. Growing Domain and Page Authority

An image of a laptop showing the word 'domain' and an icon for 'www'

Let's shift gears to two key SEO metrics: Domain Authority (DA) and Page Authority (PA).

These indicators offer a snapshot of your website's potential to rank in search engine results. A bump in your DA and PA scores is a concrete sign that your SEO strategies, particularly link-building and on-page optimization, are firing on all cylinders.

As these scores climb, it's clear evidence that your SEO campaign is not only being recognized but also rewarded by search engines. This growth reflects the strengthening of your website's SEO foundation which will, later on, result in better visibility and performance in search results.

6. Enhanced Technical Site Health

When it comes to the nitty-gritty of SEO, technical site health is a game-changer.

This aspect of SEO is all about making sure that your site is in tip-top shape for search engines like Google. Tools such as Google Search Console are your allies here, offering a clear view of your site's page speed, indexed pages and your site’s usability on mobile devices.

A healthy technical SEO status means your site is primed and ready, not just to climb the ranks in the search engine results page but also to provide a seamless user experience.

So, when you see improvements in your site’s technical health, consider this a clear indicator that your SEO campaigns are on the right track. This means more traffic and better overall website performance.

7. More Referring Domains and Quality Backlinks

The word backlinks written using a marker

Next stop—backlinks and referring domains. Think of these two as the backbone of a solid SEO strategy.

When you notice an increase in high-quality backlinks and a growing number of referring domains, it just means that your SEO efforts are finally paying off. This rise also means that other websites are finding your content both useful and worthy of a shout-out.

That’s right. It’s a nod to your site's credibility and relevance in the vast search engine landscape.

So, when your backlink portfolio grows with quality links, you can give yourself a pat on the back because your SEO project is making waves, establishing your site as an authority figure and a go-to resource in your niche.

8. Increased Conversions

Here’s another way to measure SEO performance—conversions. It's simple: More traffic, when well-targeted, leads to more conversions.

Whether your aim is increasing sales, ramping up sign-ups, or garnering more inquiries, a spike in conversions is the ultimate high-five for your SEO campaign. It's a direct reflection that your SEO efforts are attracting the right visitors.

This uptick is the tangible outcome of successful keyword research, effective use of Google Search Console insights, and a well-tuned SEO strategy. In the end, conversions are the true measure of how much traffic is actually benefiting your business goals.

9. Enhanced Visibility in Featured Snippets and SERP Features

The phrase 'search engine results page' printed on a notebook

Spotting your content in featured snippets and other SERP features is like hitting a jackpot in the SEO world. Why? Because it means your content is standing out for its relevance and quality.

This enhanced visibility is a clear indication that your SEO strategy is working wonders.

Featured snippets, in particular, mean that search engines like Google are recognizing the value of your content, placing it front and center for relevant searches.

This kind of visibility is crucial for elevating your website's performance in search results, drawing in more organic traffic numbers and showcasing your site's authority.

10. Growth in Branded Keyword Searches

A surge in searches for your brand or specific products is a clear sign that your brand is gaining notable recognition online. This is often a direct ripple effect of a well-executed SEO strategy.

At the end of the day, the main goal is to become a sought-after name in your industry. This growth reflects your SEO campaign's success in putting your brand into the minds of your audience, turning organic traffic into brand enthusiasts.

Keep in mind that this increasing trend in search volumes marks a significant victory for your SEO efforts as it highlights your website's expanding presence and influence in the online search environment.

11. More Pages Ranking

The SEO team celebrating its achievement

You know what's really exciting? Seeing not just one, but many of your website's pages climbing up in SEO rankings.

This upward trend across various pages means your SEO strategy is doing wonders across the board. This means you're nailing everything from keyword research to link building and creating a cohesive, site-wide impact.

Each page that rises in the rankings contributes to your site's overall digital footprint, showcasing the effectiveness and reach of your SEO efforts. Each page climbing the ranks in search engine result pages contributes to the overall strength and visibility of your site.


To effectively gauge your SEO performance, regularly conducting an SEO audit is essential. It helps you identify areas that need improvement and SEO opportunities you might be missing.

On top of that, you can also assess how well your website aligns with best practices in search engine optimization. Coupled with tracking key performance indicators (KPIs) through free tools like Google Analytics, you gain a comprehensive view of your SEO performance.

That’s right. These KPIs offer insights into organic traffic, page speed, and other critical metrics. Together, SEO audits and close monitoring of KPIs empower you to refine your SEO campaign effectively.

This, in turn, will guide your website toward greater success in increasing its website traffic and improving its search engine rankings.

Revitalize your SEO with LeaseMyMarketing

In search of an SEO upgrade? LeaseMyMarketing is here to help.

We're a full-service digital marketing agency focused on increasing your website traffic, visibility, and performance.

Using Google Analytics, we track your organic traffic and refine your presence on search engine results pages, focusing on the most effective organic keywords to elevate your site.

Want to see real SEO results?

Contact LeaseMyMarketing today, and let's start enhancing your online presence together.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you know if SEO is effective?

You can determine if SEO is effective by observing increases in organic traffic, improved rankings for targeted keywords, higher engagement rates (like longer average time visitors spend on the site), and more conversions from website visitors.

How do you measure SEO success?

SEO success is measured by tracking key performance indicators such as organic traffic, search engine rankings for targeted keywords, click-through rates, bounce rates, and conversion rates.

Tools like Google Analytics and Google Search Console are instrumental in providing these insights.

What is an example of a good SEO?

An example of good SEO is a website that ranks on the first page of search engine results for relevant keywords, has high-quality backlinks, features optimized content with appropriate keyword density, fast page speed, mobile-friendly design, and low bounce rates.

Good SEO also includes regularly updated, valuable content that matches user search intent.


Get all your marketing tips, trends, and best practices.

Never miss a posting by subscribing to our monthly newsletter.

bottom of page